GAAP/IFRS Convergence: The SEC’s Roadmap is a Highway Leading Nowhere

For two reasons I’ve taken a while
to step into the fray about the prospects for convergence between Generally
Accepted Accounting Principles in the United States and the International
Financial Reporting Standards.
 

First, it was an
honest and necessary but also dreary and time-consuming task to plow through the entirety of the
SEC’s statement of February 24, “In Support of Convergence and Global
Accounting Standards” – here.

Second, it was a
toss-up which was more enervating: to slog through all 68 pages of the SEC’s
turgid and repetitive bureaucratic prose, or to contemplate whether anyone thoughtful in that agency really believe in a highly-uncertain timetable that at its most optimistic extends
more than halfway through this decade. 

Although the G-20
declared in Pittsburgh last September that global standard setters should complete
their convergence project by June 2011 (here), the SEC gives itself all of next
year even to be positioned to consider a determination whether to give more support to
convergence, much less when or how. Depending on a new staff-level Work Plan
that supplants the famous “Roadmap” of 2008 (here), the SEC projects that presently-undefined
steps in implementation may be taken
no earlier than 2015 or 2016.

The merits of
convergence are debated across the spectrum, from industry sycophancy (here and here) to David Albrecht’s professorial patriotism (here) to Tom Selling’s
sour challenges to its lack of intellectual substance (here) to the playful irreverence of Going Concern (here).

For me – I am
agnostic on this point. First, the whole issue of whether convergence ought to
happen is largely academic – because the complexities and judgments within either GAAP or IFRS themselves render
the outcomes too challenging and non-comparable for any users except the
dedicated experts.    

But second, there
are understandable reasons, based entirely on process, why the SEC’s program for
convergence has more qualifiers than this month’s NCAA basketball tournament. 

On the European
side of the Atlantic, conspicuous on the personal roadmap of IASB Chairman
David Tweedie is the stop sign of his June 2011 retirement. Now a lame duck,
Tweedie has combined intellectual rigor and prickly Scottish wit, but his ability
to achieve harmony among his constituents has been frustrated by the evident
limitations on his diplomatic skills.

Disparate
nationalistic players in Europe have shown the ability to evade, frustrate
and maneuver around attempts at cross-border unification and cooperation at
many levels:

  • ·     
    The
    French bankers, abetted by no less an accounting expert than President Jacques
    Chirac, led years of lobbying to prevent the applicability of a single
    international auditing standard on derivatives accounting (here).
  • ·     
    The
    Swiss judiciary continues to provide home-court advantage in frustrating the
    on-going efforts of the American IRS to obtain personal data on alleged tax
    evaders (here).
  • ·     
    And
    eight years on from the passage of Sarbanes/Oxley, the SEC has officially permitted the PCAOB to bail for another three years (here) on its supposed mandate to inject itself
    into the inspection and oversight of ex-US accounting firms, unable to penetrate the European
    rules on privilege, privacy and confidentiality.

While on the
American side, the SEC’s guidance-writers did not have a great winter:

  • ·     
    Their late-January
    pronouncement on disclosure of the implications of climate change (here) was a
    cheerleading exercise in vacuity – see here.
  • ·     
    On the
    subject of short-selling, the SEC voted 3-2 on February 24 to re-instate an
    uptick rule (here), but only for shares dropping more than ten percent – a
    debatable exercise in cosmetics at best, that will impose obnoxious compliance
    costs while substituting the vacillations of motion for the reality of
    progress. 
  • ·     
    And on
    the subject of convergence, the flabbiness of a schedule measured in geological
    time makes clear that compared to a real roadmap, the agency’s navigators
    couldn’t find first base with a compass and a guide dog.

So on one side, the
Europeans can waffle and jawbone the convergence process for as long as it
suits – while the SEC's political dithering only kicks the can down the road, far past the tenure of any
present office-holders. Which means that the absence of accomplishment
half-a-decade from now will become the responsibility of a whole new set of
map-readers.   

It’s all enough to
speculate how Robert Frost’s 1916 poem, “The Road Not Taken,” would sound, if
written by an observer of the GAAP/IFRS process:

Two roads converged
in a wood.

And sorry I could
not see the forest for the trees,

Long I stood in the
undergrowth.

……

I shall be telling
this with a sigh

Somewhere ages and
ages hence:

Two roads never
converged

And that has made absolutely
no difference.

 

Thanks for joining this dialog. Please share
with friends and colleagues. And if not a subscriber, you are invited to sign
up at the Home page.

Leave a Reply

Stay Informed

Subscribe to get new content delivered directly to your inbox.

Post Categories

Legal

Copyright © 2025 · All Rights Reserved